Key Takeaways
-
Overlooking subtle mistakes in annuity planning can quietly eat away at your retirement income and financial security much faster than expected.
-
By slowing down, reviewing contract details, and anticipating long-term risks like inflation, taxes, and longevity, you can safeguard your retirement savings and reduce financial stress.
Taking a Deeper Look at Annuities and Your Retirement Future
Annuities are often seen as safe money investment options that provide stability in retirement. They can offer predictable income, protection against outliving savings, and peace of mind for many retirees. Yet, as reliable as annuities may appear, hidden risks and small errors in managing them can drain your retirement income more quickly than you anticipate. The key to protecting your wealth is understanding the overlooked mistakes that slowly erode savings over the course of years or even decades.
To prepare yourself, it is important to think beyond the initial purchase of the annuity and consider its role in your long-term financial picture. That means examining the contract details, tax implications, fees, and income options while also factoring in your lifestyle, family, and life expectancy.
1. Overestimating How Long Your Annuity Will Last
Not all annuities are structured for lifetime income. Some provide payments for a fixed period, such as 10, 15, or 20 years. If you live longer than the payout term, you may suddenly lose a key source of income. For example, someone who buys a 20-year annuity at age 65 could still be alive and facing financial uncertainty at 85. Considering today’s longer life expectancies, this oversight can leave you vulnerable to income shortfalls.
To avoid this, carefully review whether your annuity contract specifies lifetime income or only a fixed term. If it is time-limited, you may need to plan for additional income sources to cover the gap.
2. Misunderstanding Tax Implications
Taxes are one of the biggest drains on annuity income if not managed properly. Non-qualified annuities are taxed differently from qualified ones, and withdrawals are treated as ordinary income rather than capital gains. This can result in higher tax bills, particularly if you take large distributions. In addition, withdrawals made before age 59½ typically incur an extra penalty on top of regular income tax.
If you fail to structure withdrawals with tax planning in mind, you could give away far more to the IRS than necessary. In 2025, this is especially important because retirees often rely on multiple income streams, including Social Security and required minimum distributions, which can push you into higher tax brackets. Coordinating all of these sources with your annuity income requires careful planning.
3. Ignoring Inflation’s Long-Term Effect
Inflation steadily chips away at purchasing power over time. If your annuity offers fixed monthly payments, those payments remain the same while the cost of living increases each year. For example, what feels comfortable at age 65 may feel inadequate by age 80, when healthcare and daily expenses typically rise. Over a 20-year retirement, inflation can erode the real value of your annuity income by 30% or more if not addressed.
Some annuities include cost-of-living adjustments or riders to help offset inflation, but many do not. Failing to account for inflation can leave you financially strained in later years when expenses are often highest.
4. Overlooking Surrender Periods and Liquidity Needs
Annuities often come with surrender periods lasting 5 to 10 years. During this time, withdrawing funds can trigger steep charges, reducing your income and flexibility. Many retirees underestimate their need for liquid assets during this stage of retirement. Medical emergencies, home repairs, or supporting family can require funds at unexpected times. If you are locked into a surrender period, tapping into your annuity could become extremely costly.
Before buying, evaluate how long the surrender period lasts and whether your liquidity needs are adequately covered elsewhere. Balancing annuities with more accessible investments can help preserve your financial flexibility.
5. Forgetting to Update Beneficiary Designations
Beneficiary designations control how annuity funds are distributed after your passing. Yet many people fail to update them after major life events such as marriage, divorce, or the passing of a loved one. Outdated beneficiaries can result in funds going to the wrong person or even becoming tied up in legal disputes.
Reviewing and updating beneficiary forms every few years, or after major life events, is a small but crucial step to ensure your money goes where you intend.
6. Overlooking Fees and Hidden Charges
Annuities often include multiple layers of fees: administrative fees, mortality and expense charges, and fees for optional riders. Even if each fee seems minor, over decades these costs add up. For example, a 2% annual fee on a $200,000 annuity can reduce returns by tens of thousands of dollars over a 20-year period.
Failing to account for these ongoing costs makes it difficult to gauge the true value of your annuity. Always compare fee structures across different products and weigh whether the added benefits justify the expense.
7. Treating Annuities as Your Only Retirement Strategy
An annuity should be part of your retirement plan, not the whole plan. Relying exclusively on annuities can leave you exposed to gaps, such as limited liquidity or insufficient growth potential. Diversifying across Social Security, savings, employer-sponsored plans, and other investments provides a stronger safety net.
By treating annuities as a complement rather than the centerpiece, you can create a more resilient retirement income strategy.
8. Withdrawing Too Aggressively
It is easy to underestimate how quickly your savings can shrink if you withdraw too much, too early. High withdrawals in the first decade of retirement reduce both principal and future growth potential. They may also push you into higher tax brackets, creating further strain.
Developing a withdrawal strategy that accounts for your life expectancy, expenses, and tax brackets is essential. Many experts recommend drawing conservatively in the early years so your funds last longer.
9. Underestimating Longevity Risk
Americans are living longer than previous generations. A 65-year-old today has a strong likelihood of living into their late 80s or early 90s. Without planning for this extended lifespan, you may run out of annuity income. This risk becomes even greater if you chose a fixed-term payout rather than a lifetime option.
Factoring longevity into your retirement plan means choosing income options that last as long as you live and maintaining supplemental savings to cover additional needs.
10. Overlooking Spousal Protection
For couples, a single-life annuity may stop paying once the primary owner dies, leaving the surviving spouse without income. Many retirees fail to consider this risk. A joint-life annuity or survivor benefit option helps ensure income continues for both spouses.
Reviewing spousal benefit options before committing to a contract protects the financial stability of your household.
11. Not Considering Market Conditions Before Buying
Annuity rates are influenced by the interest rate environment. In 2024, when interest rates were higher than previous years, payout rates looked different than in 2025. Purchasing without evaluating the economic climate may mean locking into a less favorable rate. Understanding current conditions allows you to time your purchase more effectively.
Comparing options across different timelines and economic conditions can increase the long-term value of your annuity.
12. Overconfidence Without Professional Help
Annuities are complex products. Misunderstandings about contract language, tax rules, and payout structures can easily lead to costly mistakes. Some retirees assume they fully understand their annuity without seeking guidance. In reality, working with a licensed professional is one of the best ways to uncover hidden risks and align your annuity with your overall retirement goals.
In 2025, with financial markets shifting and retirement timelines lengthening, professional advice is more important than ever.
13. Neglecting to Reevaluate Over Time
A mistake many retirees make is assuming that once they purchase an annuity, no further review is needed. But retirement plans and personal circumstances change. Health issues, family needs, or new tax laws may affect how suitable your annuity is for you. Without periodic reviews, you may miss opportunities to adjust your strategy for better outcomes.
Regular check-ins every 2 to 3 years can help ensure your annuity remains aligned with your financial goals.
14. Overlooking Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs)
For annuities held within qualified retirement accounts, required minimum distributions must begin at age 73. Failing to withdraw the proper amount each year can result in penalties. Many retirees overlook this, assuming their annuity income already satisfies requirements. But the rules vary depending on how the annuity is structured.
Understanding how RMD rules apply to your annuity is essential to avoid unnecessary tax penalties.
15. Mismanaging Optional Riders
Optional riders can add valuable features, such as guaranteed withdrawal benefits or long-term care coverage. But they also increase costs. Choosing riders without evaluating whether they truly align with your needs can result in paying for features you never use. On the other hand, skipping useful riders may leave you unprotected.
Carefully assessing the pros and cons of riders before adding them helps balance protection with cost efficiency.
Protecting Your Retirement Income for the Long Run
Each mistake, whether small or large, adds up over time and can create financial strain during retirement. By carefully evaluating annuity terms, understanding tax implications, factoring in inflation, and preparing for longevity, you create a more resilient plan that keeps your retirement income intact. The retirement journey can span decades, and every choice you make today influences your comfort years down the road.
Take the time now to review your annuity strategy with a licensed professional listed on this website. Proactive adjustments today can prevent future headaches and help secure a retirement income stream that truly lasts.
